Montage: Watch the Media Uncritically Accept Another Outlandish ‘Hate Crime’

‘This is America in 2019’

When TMZ first reported that actor Jussie Smollett was the victim of a vicious hate crime, it sounded almost impossible to believe. 

Upon leaving a Chicago Subway sandwich shop circa 2 AM one sub-zero night in late January, two masked men recognized him as the openly gay black actor starring in Fox’s ‘Empire,’ hurled racist and homophobic slurs at him, beat him to the point of breaking his ribs, doused him with bleach, tied a noose around his neck, before pronouncing “This is MAGA Country!” and fleeing. 

Making such astonishing claims, the national media owed it to their viewers to give this story the circumspect coverage responsible journalism demands.

If only.

Instead the major media used their platform to uncritically parrot TMZ’s original report, even adding new details along the way (such as that the attackers wore “Make America Great Again” hats). This vicious hate crime, they said, painted a disturbing picture of America in 2019.

As Smollett’s claims have unraveled over the intervening weeks, it’s worth revisiting how the story was originally covered.

Check out the montage above to for a quick refresher. 


— Montage: ABC's Roberts Uses Interview to Try Salvaging Smollett's Sensational Story

— CNN’s Stelter on Smollett ‘Hate Crime’ Imploding: ‘This Is Not About the Media’

— Biden in Europe: America Today Is ‘an Embarrassment’

NewsList: 55 Hate Crime Hoaxes 

Column: How Smollett’s Case Fell Apart 

Like our work? Support the cause.